How I found it is anybody’s guess, but if you’ve ever stalked the byways of the night streets of the Internet, bleary towards dawn, you know that these things happen.
Somehow I came upon a page for a tourist site for
and a bronze replica of the David. The image was a postage stamp sized jpeg, 13 k maybe, but it was enough. A scrap of info located it someplace called Buffalo, New York . This was, at best, I suspected, a casting taken from the reproduction carved in 1900 to replace the real David when it was moved from the Palazzo Vecchio to the Accademia. I also knew that whatever this was, it was only two hours away from where I live in Delaware Park Pennsylvania.
Florence I’d walked icily past the marble copy in the Palazzo Signoria so as not to contaminate my experience of the real thing, a practice I would recommend to anyone serious about art. Because even though copyists, with their measuring tools, pointing machines, and immense skill could, and certainly did, bring their copy of the David to within an eighth of an inch of the real thing, it’s in that eighth of an inch, or even a sixteenth, that the magic happens. I’m something of a copyist myself, at least to the extent that I’ve made microscopically precise molds of my own sculpture using state of the art synthetic casting rubbers that will lift details finer than fingerprints, and yet the resulting castings, accurate to with microns, have lost something in the translation. Nothing is as good as the fresh clay. Something is lost even when the clay dries—yes, water, and a few percent mass, but that’s not it, or not only it. It’s the difference between a perfect copy of a perfect thing and the perfect thing itself.
And the 1900 marble David is imperfect. As would a bronze casting made from it be. In each step something is lost. Or changed, anyway.
But. On the other hand, bronze is, in itself, a magic material. Magic here meaning it is a charged material much like raw clay or cut marble. It is rich. It has power. It contributes something to the process of making sculpture. A bronze casting can be, if not better than the original, then at least as good and significantly different. Depending on what the original is made out of, the bronze can indeed be better. I take a lump of red plastecine and shape a small head and it’s good, but it’s red, and waxy and shiny, with a cheap plastic sheen. Cast in bronze, the head roars to life with a mass and weight and depth that was already there in the sculpture but hidden by the oil-base clay. I carve a figure out of foam plastic and Bondo and it looks like plastic and Bondo. But merely paint it to look like bronze and it emerges with a solidity and complexity and depth that turn the swirls of Bondo into nuanced modeled textures.
So a trip to
Buffalo to see a bronze casting of a David, even if it’s a casting of a replica David has merit, because the Buffalo David may be distinguishable from the real thing, but the bronze will add its own music. It will react with the air around it to fill in that critical and otherwise unforgiving eighth-inch with vibratory metallic energy and Michelangelo’s David will exist full blast, full-bore right there in front of me, all for the cost of a quarter tank of gas.
Oh, we are going to
. Delaware Park
It’s a hot Saturday July 16 and we are on our way. As we drive to
Buffalo I’ll answer some quick questions. Why was I up late prowling on-line? I work a graveyard shift. Why do I work a graveyard shift? I gave up teaching my writing workshops. I gave up teaching sculpture. I closed my studio and gallery. I dumped my writing clients. I shuttered m small y publishing house. I all but dropped out of the art crit scene, reviewing only those exhibitions that I really thought needed to be cover or I thought could be allow me to hammer home for some point I thought was important. I took a low-pressure, low-pay job as the night manager at a restored Victorian inn that once flourished in the late 1800s with the health nut frenzy of “the waters” of , the drinking of, and bathing in which was believed to prevent disease and restore heath. It was a big deal. Thousands of people came from all over the country. Many great hotels grew. Forty trains a day stopped to deposit the supposedly ill and reuptake the supposedly newly healthy. The fad passed. Cambridge Springs fell on hard times from which it has not yet recovered except that here in this one last standing hotel—the rest of them burnt down—prosperity retains its tenuous purchase, and I sit here, five nights a week, 11:00 to 7:00, in case anybody wants anything, which they almost never do. I read all night. I read about the Italian Renaissance. I write about Michelangelo. I am left alone. It pays the bills, barely. I am saving up for a third trip to Cambridge, Pennsylvania Rome in March. It could be worse.
The bronze David is powerful. The bronze itself adds some missing dimension as it catches the sun coming in hard from the east, and splashing white against the dark blue-green.
It’s a windy day. The sky is clear. The David is real. I’m all the more made aware of the line about the real David in his Florentine alcove in the Accademia, as being trapped “in a birdcage.” We never see the David in any light other than the one uniform artificial light of the gallery. But outside, here in
Buffalo, the light is already moving—a bit sharper even in the few minutes I’ve circled it taking pictures. I think about coming back in the evening to see what it’ll look like with deep orange sunset lighting it, face-on. I consider coming up throughout the year and seeing what the light does, maybe talking to whoever is in charge and getting permission to bring a ladder or a bucket lift to get close-ups—do a whole series: “David in New York.” Pitch a book to Taschen.
None of this is diluting, nor is a record of the dilution of, the experience of confrontation with this immense being. He is Adam thinking, “Uh oh, God’s coming!” He’s Jesus looking at the cross. He’s Superman, Joshua, Julius Caesar. “We’re counting on you.” “You are, huh?” He’s Michelangelo himself. “Can I pull this off?” “I can pull this off.” David flung a stone at Goliath; Michelangelo will sling this stone at history. No wonder he thought he could do anything after he’d done this.
And here on this copse we can stand farther back than we ever can at the Accademia, and see the figure far off, his back to us, standing on the horizon. We can pull away and see him through the trees, vanishing against the sky.
We can get in close and stare up and up and up.
“. . . man, he doth bestride the narrow world / Like a Colossus, and we petty men / Walk under his huge legs and peep about.”
We walk back to the car and I wonder what it looks like at night. Does it catch city-light? It’s right on highway 198 east. What would passing headlights do in a time exposure? We may find out.
Heading home, nearly back home, we are in northwest
Pennsylvania rolling down a two-lane blacktop. Route 19. I don’t usually go this way, but I know it, and it’s a little different and possibly a little quicker
My partner Diana wants to stop at an antique store, a junk shop, really, secondhand knickknacks a few decades old, cheap glass vases, rusty veterinary irrigation syringes, and tin muffin pans. The place is full of crumbling wicker, tarnished coffee pots, moldy books, a few mediocre kitchen chairs, and rusty toolboxes. Things with chickens painted on them. I am killing time. Diana is accumulating stuff. I’m tired. I’ve been driving. My back hurts. I’m thirsty. I want to go home. And then: “You are kidding me.”
There on a shelf of chochkees is a little figure, maybe 4 inches tall. I may be the only guy in a fifty-mile radius who knows what it is. I pick it up. “Look at this,” I say to Diana. “This is a souvenir knockoff of a sculpture by a minor nineteenth century artist, Cesare Zocchi. The original is about two-thirds life-size. It’s marble. Get this. It’s “The Boy Michelangelo Carving the Mask of a Faun.” What are the odds?
It’s a little cast plaster figurine, in cheap bronze paint, but it’s not bad, not a bad job. The original is a piece of nineteenth century realistic vignette dreck. However, as earnestly chintzy as it is (the original), it has found an odd little purchase in art history simply as an illustration of Michelangelo as a boy. There he is, hunched over, a chisel in his left hand, a mallet in his right, his clothing detailed to within an inch of its life, as he taps away. For what it is, it’s really well done. But like Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema’s 1868 painting of “Phidias Showing the Frieze of the Parthenon to his Friends” it’s just so very nineteenth century illustration.
Buffalo David was exactly sublime but the Zocchi isn’t exactly ridiculous.
But as a bookend to this trip? It’s perfect.
Twenty bucks? No no no no no. I’m not coughing up twenty bucks for this.
Diana says, “You have to get that. Offer ‘em fifteen.” And the intense synchronicity starts to really hit me. Yes, I do have to get this because, after all, what the hell is it doing here? Who once bought it? Who, for that matter, made it? What home thought it needed a little figurine of Michelangelo as a boy sculpting the head of a faun? Around here? How did this happen? How did it happen that in remote rural deerhunter country, a passing customer looks down and says, “Zocchi”? And “The original is in the Casa Buonarotti.”
I've seen Zocchi’s other work. It’s what you’d expect.
Melodramatic 19th century dramaturgy, arms flailing, histrionics wound tight and tent-pegged to a grim bedrock realism. They thought they were following in Michelangelo’s footsteps. They all did. For three hundred years and change, 1564 to 1878. They all thought Michelangelo was a realist. I think back to the
Buffalo David and Diana’s sudden realization that his right hand is too big. It’s never hit her before. “Yeah,” I say, “it’s too big. This isn’t a realistic sculpture. Nothing Michelangelo ever did was realistic. At all. He wasn’t a realist.”
I’m looking at the little Zocchi sitting on top of a stack of books. In its own way it isn’t realistic either. It’s idealized—a distillation of Zocchi’s reading of Michelangelo, the eternal earnest force. The stone boy carving himself.